MenCalc or MEncodeMe crop/resize
 

I go with MEncodeMe for KSVCD PAL (480x576) and I want use overscan=2.

I set 432x544 in MEncodeMe CROP values.

If I edit temp.conf of MEncodeMe, I see this settings:

With MenCalc for overscan factor=2:

I must edit temp.conf every time in MEncodeMe for replace the correct values?

Thanks.

-Maurus

As I did explain you here:
http://www.kvcd.net/forum/viewtopic....177&highlight=
(so opening another thread like this one is not necessary as it "splits" the subjects ;-) ).

That "would" result in a wrong cropping!
As like in Avisynths crop() ... you have to determine "where" to crop these 432x544 out of the orig 480x576! And thats not -1,-1
(but ... Im not shure!! if a "-1" does tell mencoder to crop "centered"!! If yes, that would be very nice! .... so do me a favor as Im at work on a MAC now ... and run a short encoding comparing the following - also quoted by you - line:

Sorry, for open similar two thrads... :oops:

In crop crop=432:544:-1:-1, the last two values are for Center.

The line:

is created for MEncodeMe.

The line:

is from MenCalc with overscan factor=2.

For your explanation, I think than this last line is more correct for overscan=2 and add black borders as I want.

Thanks for all.

-Maurus

Nice Info!

:D

....

(Speaking to myself: "And where the hell is that mentioned in the manual!" :evil: :lol: )

I don't want to bother your yourself conversation but...
and default values for crop are:
from http://www.mplayerhq.hu/DOCS/man/en/manpage.html

One question though:
Shouldn't the order be crop,scale,expand ?

The mplayer documentation mention that some filters, like deinterlacing,
should take place "after cropping and before scaling" (section 7.12.2.3).

And I think encoding should be faster if you crop unnessecery parts before
scaling.

- Peder

I think it is like avs scripts. You aply some filters before resizing and some others after it. IMHO you always must to use Addborders (like expand) in last place, after any other filter. This is in this way because you don't need aply filters to black borders.



--------------------------
Visit: Intermediate guide: MencodeMe/Win32 - Avisynth - MakeAvis by Prodater64.
Visit: KVCD - MencodeMe - Auxiliar Task - KVCD Docking Gate by Prodater64.
Visit: Mencoder scripting with AVSEdit and Guide for Multiple Files by Prodater64.
Visit: Mini-guide quick and easy - DVD to (S)KVCD with MencodeMe by Maurus.
Visit: Mencode-me: a newbie oriented GUI - 0.23 is out! by VMesquita.
--------------------------

Except that it seems to have a kind of "intelligence" within mencoder. For instance Kwag already tested that adding noise does'nt affect the black borders created by "expand".

Nope, the borders are added after encoding. I'm not even sure the
borders are a part of the mpg; they're probably just a flag telling the
player "add some black here".
And noise should be applied before cropping/scaling.

But I still think the correct order is to crop before scale.
My hunch is that the scaling is done while encoding (or right before) and in
the scale/crop case you'd encode information that you later on crop away.

That should be even more noticeable if the source isn't 16/9 but say
1.85:1. If you scale first (and my guess about encoding is right) then
you're encoding the black bars as well.

- Peder

Hi Peder,

a) black borders are "part" of the encoding!
If you deal with an anamorph source THEN the height on a 4:3 output will be squeezed by h/1.333 and then the player adds black borders ... so what you mean is a classical "letterboxing". But the Blackborders in the m2v/m1v where done while encoding and not put after.

b) Noise adding before scaling is the worst you can do as individual scaling processes will totally affect the size of the noises grain!

c) When the image gets into an encoder and if its in the encoder prefered colorspace, then that WHOLE image will be processed before, means cropping/scaling etc. will be done on the image data before it goes into the DCT process.

No matter if you first crop, first scale or first filter, ... at the end you get a treated image which goes into the DCT engine ...

I did many tests and had no probs when first scaling and then cropping (btw. thats also the way explained in the reference link in my application, so theres no problem if cropping before or after scaling.

According to filters, you can still set them after after Cropping/scaling or scaling/cropping. Same in avisynth.

@ All

New version is out 1.01.00 I rewrote the routine where now also all non PAR 1:1 avis are supported, means still 16:9 Avis via DVD2AVI/AVISynth/Makeavis processes, and for shure common capture resolutions in NTSC and PAL.

http://home.arcor.de/packshot/mencalc1.01.0.exe

Looking good Inc. ;)

-kwag

Thanks!

Iv ben searchin around the web for a icon Builder .... the one I got is going to "die" in 30days and its a crap!
Do you know a good one?? :( :)

Try Icon Sushi - it's freeware, and very good.

I'll edit this with the url when I find it.

http://towofu.s5.xrea.com/soft/e-index.html

NICE!!! Thanks a lot! :)