KDVD Standalone Compatibility Samples
 

Hi all,

You always wonder what are the capabilities of your standalone regarding to KDVD ? I also do.

So, I compiled a "KDVD Samples" volume. This DVD contains a movie sample about 1'20" long encoded in :

#1 - 352*288 MPEG2 - 4/3
#2 - 352*576 MPEG2 - 16/9
#3 - 480*576 MPEG2 - 16/9
#4 - 544*576 MPEG2 - 16/9
#5 - 704*576 MPEG2 - 16/9
#6 - 704*576 MPEG2 - 16/9 - LONG GOP (25 insteed of 15)

The NTSC volume contains a 43' long video encoded in :

#1 - 352*240 MPEG2 - 4/3
#2 - 352*480 MPEG2 - 16/9
#3 - 480*480 MPEG2 - 16/9
#4 - 544*480 MPEG2 - 16/9
#5 - 704*480 MPEG2 - 16/9
#6 - 704*480 MPEG2 - 16/9 - LONG GOP (25 insteed of 15)

All samples where done with the same script, using CCE (with Vmesquita template) except for the last one that was done with TMPGENC. This way you can compare also the two encoders if you want to ;-)

Last : I adapted the Q factor (or CQ for last one) of each sample in order to have exactly the same filesize. That means that all samples above lead the same target size on the end. So you can compare too the visual quality of each resolution for a given target !

I put the sample on edonkey :

KDVD Standalone Compatibility Samples - PAL.rar (141.01 MB)
KDVD Standalone Compatibility Samples - NTSC.rar (61.27 MB)

I also put them under Konspire, into my own channel KVCD.net - Dialhot's channel.

Note1: sample #1 is actually 4:3 but declared as 16:9 by the authoring software (DVD-lab) that couldn't mix both 4:3 and 16:9 on the same disc.

Note2 : audio is 128 Kbit/s - MP2 but it does not really matter.

FINAL NOTE : My standalone (pioneer D454) plays everything :-D. I'm quite sure a lot of standalones will do.

Dialhot,

This was really a great idea, now everyone can know what their stand-alones are up to in DVD. But just one side note: the official KDVD uses standard resolutions/GOP. I believe it's important to make this statement because a lot of people in the past have not used KVCD for it being non-standard, and now in KDVD, you can keep the standard and yet have very high quality (and minutes) on DVD. And of course, if the player supports non-standard resolutions... Let the fun begin. :D :D

For sure, that is why I add also a test with non standard GOP, encoded with tmpgenc.

Because if your standalone support all the resolutions (like my TWO ones, I just did test on the Philips DV737) and the long GOP _and_ if you did you KVCD in MPEG2 then you can put all your old KVCD on a DVD simply by resampling the audio to 48 khz :!:

Next test to do : check standalone capabilities with MPEG1 streams ! :-)

just a shame the file is so big with me bein on dialup its fifficult to get hold of it, an when I went to download the file i got no sources.

Wow! Phil, that image is really big! :wink:

But anyway, nice Idea and thanks for your work! :)

I wanted to test the new official DL channel for KVCD but didn't manage to make it work yet. Kwag just gave me some hints and I will test as soon as my current DL are finished (within an hour) :-)

BTW I will make a smaller NTSC project.

Note : it is not an image but a VIDEO_TS directory that you have to burn with whatever you use to.

@andy
I'm on razorbak2 as server and you can find ly source there. For the next 23 hours, the direct link to my PC will be :

ed2k://|file|KDVD.Standalone.Compatibility.Samples.-.PAL.rar|147855357|1AD1FAAF7D927FDEA26E8C0F2F39393 0|/|sources,81.51.27.129:4892|/

Edit: I put it on konspire. Under "KVCD.net - Dialhot's channel".
I hope I understood how this stuff works

I'm not using edonkey as I can never seem to get it connected to the net but I am using a program called shareaza which can handle edonkey links and I finally got sources for it to download from woo hoo hehehehe

Did you set your broadcast to "Continuous" :?:
Because I still can't see the channel :roll:

-kwag

@Kwag
Yes I do.

@Andy
I'm currently uploading to a mysterious AndyB on Shareazaa :-)
I set you a friend slot. So you will continue to UL till the end of the file (as you are my only client at the moment :-p))

:roll: whos to say thats me :lol: well it says about 8 - 10 hrs to download the file so that should be fun :D

Hum gotta try that 544x576 as I have a pioneer DV444 it may works , 528x576 didnt though.

I've tried MPEG1 480x576 and it works fine on DVD

Subscribed and downloading ;)

-kwag

wonderful idea Phil!

waiting for ntsc samples!
:wink:

Nice !! I made miniDVD from that and my Philips 728 played all samples !

Wouaw ! SOme standalones can REALLY eat everything :-)

@Dialhot,

Just checked my subscriptions, and your "channel", and I see the file "KDVD Standalone Compatibility Samples - NTSC.rar" being downloaded :cool:
File size 62,745.50 so that should be here later tonight ( because I'm also running MUTE with about 20 download streams :mrgreen: )

-kwag

NTSC SAMPLES ARE HERE !

I edited my first post - go read it for details.
Karl, can you turn this post into a "Announce" or "Sticky" post ? Thank you. Or perhaps put a message under "What's happening"

I didn't even have the time to post a message :-)

Note: tell me if there is an error because I didn't have the time to test it on the standalone. I just whatched the result on the PC.

I know :!:
That's how fast it works :o
The download started automatically :D
It's already 10% done 8O :lol:

-kwag

Damn, Now I understand why the i-net has been so slow on the last couple of days :mnkypile: