Best lossy capturing software to use with VC500?
I've decided to not bother with capturing loseless using VD, it seems completely unnecessary since my sources are "good enough" and I don't need to bother doing any editing or post-cleanup. So I was wondering what is the best lossy capturing software to use with the Diamond VC500? Should I just use the software it comes with or is there a better alternative? I'm assuming MPEG-2 would be the best choice for "lossy" capturing?
|
The best lossy solution is probably a DVD recorder with HDD that IsoBuster supports for reading the drive to retrieve the recordings. In fact you could treat the HDD like a VHS tape and shelve it until your ready to read it later, swapping in a new HDD as needed.. as long as you bought a copy of IsoBuster to use when you finally decide to copy the recordings to a PC.
Since that works on Windows XP through W10 and on a Mac and Linux its about as generic and lazy a method as you could get. Even if you don't plan to post process.. however.. I would recommend recording at the highest bit rate the recorder is capable of capturing at. |
I'm aware that the JVC DR-M10 and DR-M100 are both excellent DVD Recorders for capturing, however, I'm looking to capture directly to my PC using my Diamond VC500. Are you suggesting that using a DVD Recorder is a better solution?
|
A Diamond or any Capture device that does not have hardware compression assist is still going to require full Uncompressed bandwidth to the PC. Then the CPU of the PC will have to perform the compression no matter which codec you decide to use. Or you will have have to capture Uncompressed, then compress later.
The JVC DR-M10 and DR-M100 have a file system on them which I kind of understand.. but not well enough to suggest to the IsoBuster author that it be supported. They are not supported at this time. |
Hmm, very interesting, I wasn't expecting this sort of response. I suppose I don't really have a problem capturing loseless first and then compressing, but I just assumed it would be quicker to capture directly to a lossy format.
I'm very familiar with IsoBuster and have used it in the past. Although now a days I use makemkv for all my blu-ray and DVD ripping needs. Have you tried using it on discs created by the DR-M10 and DR-M100? One thing that has me questioning your advice about NOT using the VC500, is that I have done some preliminary testing with some hardware I have here at home right now. That workflow consists of a Crappy Memorex VCR > Composite Cable > WinTV-HVR 950Q > PC, and then capturing lossy using the WinTV software. Now as crappy as that workflow might be, I have gotten very acceptable results! So I can't imagine how having better hardware is going to make my workflow any worse? Not once did I experience any "lock-up's" or "quits" at any time. But then again, it could be because I'm using Windows 7 and not that abomination Windows 10. Right now I'm waiting for some new equipment to arrive, JVC S9800 VCR, Diamond VC500, and a Sony DCR-TRV460 D8 Camcorder. I've got about 12 VHS tapes I need to convert, and about 15 Hi8/8mm tapes to convert as well. For the Hi8/8mm tapes I planned on using the TRV460 > Firewire > PC, capturing lossy using WinDV. For the VHS tapes I planned on using the S9800 > S-Video > VC500 > PC, and then capturing lossy MPEG-2. Now the Camcorder that I ordered also has the ability to go from Analog to Digital so another workflow I have considered for the VHS conversion is, S9800 > S-Video > TRV460 > Firewire > PC. BTW my computer is custom built, i7 3.4GHz, 32GB RAM, GeForce RTX 2070, m.2 SSD for the OS drive, a couple of SATA SSD's for various things (virtual machines, encoding etc.), and I've got two 10TB HDD's as well. Any other thoughts or suggestions? |
Quote:
Yes, there is really low-end crappy software like ArcSoft ShowBiz, but it's seriously so terrible that you may as well not even bother transferring the videos. AIW ATI, and some older specific Hauppauge cards, are really the only viable non-$1k cards that capture to lossy formats, namely MPEG in this case. H264/AVC cards expect non-analog sources. Quote:
Quote:
- That VCR will probably output an image with visual timing wiggles and chroma noise/flaws/issues. - That 950Q capture card cooks values. - Composite creates dot crawl and chroma/color bleed. I would be beyond surprised if it was truly a quality signal. Quote:
(1) halt due to anti-copy (2) capture driver problems Unsure which you mean. Quote:
You're missing the external TBC. Lack of TBC usually leads to quality and captureability issues. Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
|
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
|
The 960Q is a low-end card, and WinTV is not good for the USB cards. Quality is pretty lousy. Worse than even a cheap DVD recorder.
|
MPEG-2 Capture with VC500
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Site design, images and content © 2002-2024 The Digital FAQ, www.digitalFAQ.com
Forum Software by vBulletin · Copyright © 2024 Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.