Is the dvd interlaced or progressive?
 

I would want to know like making in order to know if a dvd it is interlaced or progressive?

thanks

hy zagor !

the dvd is ripped in hd?
if don't ,do it!
load the vobs(ripped)in dvd2avi,

MOVE TO A FST MOVING SCENE USING DVD2AVIs slider below and watch if its interlaced (combing) or not! If its combed = 29.976 NTSC Interlaced, if its not combed = 23.976 NTSC Progressive and that means check "Force film" in DVD2AVI.

thanks inc & Phil !
:wink:

< edited >
now is ok!

As told, do not only take notice of the statistics window:

MOVE TO A FST MOVING SCENE USING DVD2AVIs slider below and watch if its interlaced (combing) or not! If its combed = 29.976 NTSC Interlaced, if its not combed = 23.976 NTSC Progressive and that means check "Force film" in DVD2AVI. :wink:

NO !!!
Jorel you know that what is said by DVD2AVI can't be trusted ! You have actually this problem in this thread :

http://www.kvcd.net/forum/viewtopic.php?t=9122&start=32

The only tool to know if a DVD is interlaced or not are YOUR EYES.

You open the vobs in DVD2AVI, you drag the cursor and you watch if you see any comb effects.

Edit: you beat min Inc :-)

:oops:
was my poor english friends!
i wrote:
"..press "F5" and see the "statistics window" for few minutes."
but will be:
see the image and details for few minutes!!

inc wrote:
"As told, do not only take notice of the statistics window: "
right inc ,i remember!

Phil wrote:
"Jorel you know that what is said by DVD2AVI can't be trusted ! You have actually this problem in this thread :"
yes Phil, i really had this problems.

sorry everybody for my incomplete and unclear information!

zagor, this is the right way:
"MOVE TO A FST MOVING SCENE USING DVD2AVIs slider below and watch if its interlaced (combing) or not! If its combed = 29.976 NTSC Interlaced, if its not combed = 23.976 NTSC Progressive and that means check "Force film" in DVD2AVI.
thanks inc & Phil!
:wink:

reply
 

I have understood. :D
Yesterday, I have tried 2 dvd (pal) and dvd2avi he brought back that they were interlaced.
as dialhot said in an other post that 90% of the dvd are progressive, has come to me a doubt.
This evening I will try to house in order to see if they are interlaced or not.
thanks

@jorel
don't worry jorel :wink:

@incredibile
My dvd is Pal!
:D

Re: reply
 

The fact is simple :

- a movie is shot in 24 im/s and when the producers make the master for doing a DVD they just speed up the framerate to 25 im/s. In NTSC zone they use 23.976 progressive and set the pulldown flag on because a standalone request a DVD to be in 29.970 interlaced.
(23.976p is called MOVIE mode, 29.970i is called VIDEO mode)

- a documentary or a TV show is already shot in 25 im/s interlaced so the DVD will also be in 25i.

:arrow: doing a 25 interlaced video from a 24 im/s movie claims for more work for the producers.

Work = time = money = THEY (almost) NEVER DO THAT.

That's why I told that 90% of the DVD are progressive.

this thread deserve a Sticky, is a good and fast tutorial :!: