Best capturing for large 82-100" HDTV playback?
Hi LordSmurf,
First, I want to take a moment to thank you for creating DigitalFAQ. I especially enjoyed your very helpful and easy to digest guides on ATI All-in-Wonder capture cards. When I got started with video capturing in 2004, I worked off your guides exclusively and was extremely satisfied with the results. In fact, when my system died due to a power surge in 2008, I tried a few alternatives before I eventually relented and purchased a new custom built computer that had AGP so I could continue using the ATI card. In any event, I'm trying to determine where to go next. I have an 82" television and a hi-def projector capable of projecting images at about 100". I still have a few hundred VHS tapes that I would like to convert to some digital medium. I am thinking of simply capturing the tapes to MPEG using the ATI card and storing the raw MPEGs on a 3TB hard drive which I can access and stream to my TV or projector via a server (For what it's worth, I plan on utilizing two 3 TB drives and keeping one for backup purposes only). I'm wondering if you have any thoughts on the viability of this. Is MPEG still a good format for capture and playback in this manner? In addition, I may need to occasionally burn DVDRs from these files, so a format that could be easily converted would be desirable. Should I consider AVI and possibly Huffy? I also imagine anything I capture will have to be done with DVD specs in mind. Thanks in advance, Justin --justin81
|
Hello, and thanks for your kind words. And most humbled that you had used my methods. :)
The larger the viewing device, the more obvious errors and noise are. And the more compressed a format is, the more likely it will have noise and errors. VHS was a noisy consumer analog tape format, for example. And then MPEG-2 can be a very lossy format, depending on quite a few variables, including source and encoding method. While VHS captured directly to MPEG-2 (on the ATI AIW cards) looked fine on SDTVs of the era, and even HDTVs up to 60" (with playback filters), I'd be lying if I said the picture would be excellent at 80-100". I'd honestly have this workflow, for that source: 1. Capture to lossless Huffyuv AVI. 2. Carefully filter the video with Avisynth and/or VirtualDub, to remove encoding-resistant noise and errors. 3. Encode to H.264 MPEG-4 with a very decent bitrate. Or high bitrate MPEG-2 (15-25Mbps). That would yield an awesome image. :) But that would also result in a Blu-ray or streamed-only version. For a "DVD version", simply encode a normal bitrate MPEG-2 as an alternate Step 3. Do both -- one "the best", one for DVD-Video format. If you have more questions, just ask. :) __ Note: Sorry for the slow reply to this question -- tech questions asked through PMs and emails are answered much slow than posts. Always ask here on this forum, in posts, for the quickest replies. |
Site design, images and content © 2002-2024 The Digital FAQ, www.digitalFAQ.com
Forum Software by vBulletin · Copyright © 2024 Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.