![]() |
Protect optical discs from light damage?
What are the harmful effects of light on the optical media CD / DVD? the difference between direct sunlight and indirect sunlight? my home during the day receives brightness and clarity of sunlight but is not a light focused sun> DVD, this sunlight that comes into my house will damage the optical disc CD / DVD in the long term?
|
Light alters dye. Keep discs in dark non-moist areas.
Yes, it will be damaged if kept in light. Put discs inside cupboards, closets, dark cases, etc. Ever think about why DVDs come in black cases from the store, and not transparent ones? That's why. |
What kind of light is harmful to the CD / DVD?
Store the disk in a slim case CD with cover in front protects the disc from the light? see the photohttp://www.digitalfaq.com/forum/imag...ILIPSCDR-1.jpg |
All of it is bad.
True, some cases are completely clear. But companies make all kinds of stupid things. For example, "DVD safe" markers (nonsense). But most CDs and DVDs come in packaging that blots out light. And again, that's for a reason, not because it's the fashion. |
My dvd and cd disk this unprotected light that case slim cd with front cover? light passes through and damage dye? behind the case slim black color
http://www.digitalfaq.com/forum/imag...35MLB157-1.jpg |
Quote:
|
Direct sunlight to discs is harmful for two reasons:
The sunlight's ultraviolet photons (the higher frequency of the sunlight spectrum) have enough energy to produce a photochemical reaction, altering the optical properties of the dye (recording layer) molecules. The broad spectrum of unfiltered sunlight, infrared to ultraviolet (low frequency to high), can impart heat to the disc. The increased temperature generated by sunlight will accelerate the degradation or breakdown of the dye layer (recording layer) of the disc. The combination of high temperature and high relative humidity will further accelerate that degradation. |
indirect sunlight and fluorescent lamps destroy the CD / DVD?
|
Quote:
|
indirect sunlight and light from the fluorescent lamp takes how long to damage the optical disc?
|
Quote:
That like asking: "How long can I stick my finger in an electric socket before I die?" It's bad, don't do it, the end. 'How long' is immaterial. From a purely academic stance, "it depends". The type of dye will determine this more than anything else, with anything cyanine-based croaking first. Perhaps M-Disc will fair better here, but light absorbance is the least of its issues. |
All kinds of light damage the CD / DVD?
My dvd and cd disk this unprotected light that case slim cd with front cover? light passes through and damage dye? behind the case slim black color http://www.digitalfaq.com/forum/imag...3/phcdrw-1.jpg |
Quote:
Quote:
|
see another photo CD slim case, this case will protect the disk of light? behind is black in front is transparent (or cover) case slim cd protect light in CD/DVD?
http://www.digitalfaq.com/forum/imag...NE_HIRES-1.jpg |
Black = fine. It's black.
|
Black avoids light on the disc?
http://www.digitalfaq.com/forum/imag...coline_1-1.jpg the front up of disc CD/DVD may receive light without damaging the dye? http://www.digitalfaq.com/forum/imag...03/sl225-1.jpg |
"Yes" to both questions.
|
1 Attachment(s)
Quote:
2 the front layer of the CD / DVD disc which is the barrier that prevents the light from having contact with the dye? 3 the arrows will go enter light on the dye disc? white paper case CD/DVD protects the disc from the light? paper is not transparent on the behindhttp://www.digitalfaq.com/forum/imag...416_orig-1.jpg |
Bottom line:
Any light (and probably including "light" the human eye can not sense) can, over time, damage recordable optical media such as DVD-R/+R, BD-R, CD, etc. There is no way to reliably predict how much and how fast without a lot of instrumentation and test results for the specific media involved. Storing media in a light tight container (or even a dark closet with no windows) can mitigate this. Thermal cycling (changes in temperature) cause stresses to the physical media that will accelerate deterioration over time, especially at bonds/joints. Think of it as a bit like bending a wire repeatedly - eventually it will break. Storing media to avoid wide temperature swings will mitigate this; e.g., in an insulated closet that keeps a relatively constant temperature, with perhaps for air conditioning to avoid high temperatures if your ambient temperatures average above the manufacturers specified conditions. Holding humidity constant, at the manufacturers specification will mitigate the potential for accelerated damage due to high humidity and swings. Installing a dehumidifier for your storage space can help with this. Museums and professional archives do this - they control their environment and access to minimize deterioration of the artifacts they store due to radiation (including light), temperature, humidity, and handling. Of course, if you want to display your collection, all bets are off. No one can predict what will happen to your media or the recordings you have beyond that they will deteriorate over time. They can only suggest what may make things some what better, or worse, and it is up to you to do what every you feel is necessary to protect your recordings. The bottom line is the only reasonably assured way to preserve the recordings is to have off-site backups, and to test, and to rerecord before you start to get uncorrectable errors. And that means periodic assessment of you recordings. How much longer do you plan to live? Is there anyone who will be interested in your recording after you pass (i.e., an "interested third party"? You may want to manage the recordings to last your lifetime, and let the "interested third party" worry about them beyond then. And realistically speaking, finding working media players for old media (78 RPM records, 45s, LPs, reel-to-reel tapes, 8-track tapes, minidisc, Beta, VHS, S-VHS, 8mm, Hi8, D8, laser disk, Beta, etc. is becoming problematic. Some of these formats go back less than 10 years old. Be sure to consider your "next generation storage" plan to future-proof the important stuff, if there is any. The media giants are doing this today as they re-release old film, video tape, VHS and DVD stuff on Blu-ray and streaming formats. And they are, no doubt working on whats next. What comes after Blu-ray? I do not know, but some argue for streaming content (yours or someone else's) from central data store over broadband - to any device anywhere. |
Answer my questions above case paper
|
Visible light can pass through all the paper and tyvek sleeves I have seen (don't know about other wave lengths). It just is translucent, light is scattered (to prevent a coherent image from being seen through it - just shadows). If light can pass through it, it has potential to effect optical media.
Keep your recorded media in a light-tight box, cabinet, or closet to minimize this. |
my CD and DVD stored in case of paper is in a horizontal position where the disk top face receives direct light, the part of the disc behind does not receive direct light as it is lying, this disc will be damaged by light?
|
Maybe.
Keep your recorded media in a light-tight box, cabinet, or closet to minimize this. |
Some CDs / DVDs my station stored in this horizontal position on the paper case, the light will enter the disk going to dye and disc damage?http://www.digitalfaq.com/forum/imag...fontbPla-1.jpg
|
Quote:
|
Consider: http://www.verbatim.com/subcat/optical-media/m-disc/
Costs more, but potentially longer life, the recorded layer is more resistant to heat, humidity, and light. |
the CD / DVD disc horizontally in white paper case on a table or on another disk light will go behind the discs? the front side is exposed to light, but the back of disc receive light?
|
Note: paper sleeves are in contact with the surface of the media and any dirt or other "stuff" that gets into the sleeve will be in contact with the media, and could scratch or embed in the media surface as it is moved within the sleeve or in contact for a long time. Paper sleeves are not a good option for long term storage. But they are cheap for delivery of disks to third parties :P.
Note that optical media includes transparent plastic outer and edge layers. Light can enter from the edge of the media, not just through the play side surface. Black DVD library cases the better option - they effectively protect from light and direct contact with the media surface, and can reduce the rate (e.g., degrees-per-hour) that room temperature and RH changes reach the media. Just beware of inferior (often cheap) cases that may still be out-gassing :hot: chemicals left over from manufacturing. You might find this web page of interest http://www.hughsnews.ca/faqs/authori...e-and-disposal And keep in mind that Murphy's law assures us that no matter what you do, the most important recording will be the one to fail first, and usually sometime during the day before you really need it :depressed:. |
I have CD / DVD discs in two types of cases, the case of paper and slim case with a black bottom, all disks are stored in a horizontal position, if I light a fluorescent lamp or the sun indirect light is present these lights They will enter the disk damaging the dye? theoretically the light would have to go to the front of the disks
http://www.digitalfaq.com/forum/imag...wel_Case-1.jpg http://www.digitalfaq.com/forum/imag...cdsleeve-1.jpg |
Unless the disc is in a light tight container, light can reach the disk. This applies to the slim plastic CD jewel cases with a clear cover on one side as in your #29 photo. Light can enter via the edge of the disk and some will reach the dyes. Whether or not it will unrecoverably damage the recording will depend on the dyes, the intensity and wavelength of the light, and the duration of exposure as well as other environmental and handling factors, not the least of which are manufacturing variations from one lot to the next.
All of this has been discussed in depth in this (and other) threads and reference links, and you have been given many suggestion as to how to mitigate the risks. Nothing you, or I, or anyone else lurking here, can say will change the physics of media degradation over time and exposure. At this point believe what you wish and act accordingly but do not expect anyone to give you a precise prediction as to media life in your situation. |
This is a situation would be I did not know that the light came on CD / DVD by the edge, I have no other case and my discs were in the white paper case and slimcase exposed to indirect sunlight and fluorescent light all day and evening, the disc edge was protected I would not have this concern but I think my discs will die fast
http://www.digitalfaq.com/forum/imag...3/5n6stt-1.jpg Lordsmurf The light on the dye through the edge of the CD / DVD disc? what photo the best case type for preserv long term storage cd and dvd? i buy in brazil |
In the light of this and previous similar discussions I am sure the discs will die long before we are all fin(n)ished with the subject :)
|
what photo the best case type for preserve long term storage cd and dvd? i buy in brazil
case dvd is very good or bad to preserve cd / dvd media? I thought about buying these cases (slim, fat) for storage my verbatim medias but need to know if it is the best option to protect the disc of light, moisture, heat http://www.digitalfaq.com/forum/imag...41257617-1.jpg http://www.digitalfaq.com/forum/imag...aseBlack-1.jpg http://www.digitalfaq.com/forum/imag...6/08/312-1.jpg Lordsmurf help my question please dvd case Amaray is good for preserve optical media? |
You keep asking me for answers I cannot give.
- Can it? Yes. - Will it? I cannot guarantee this. Some cases are excellent, some are garbage. Example: I've had Amaray that were really nice. But I've also had Amaray that went in the trash. Wrose yet, "Amaray" is misused a lot, so those "Amaray" cases are sometimes not even Amaray. You can blame the high variability of plastics, especially when using cheaper recycled plastics (and many DVD cases do). So, please, quit asking me this. You already have my answers. Slim cases can scratch media, as many have not protection between the lower polycarbonate and the plastics of the case. You need a small bumper to keep the surfaces from touching, and most all "full" cases (or even multi-disc) are like this. |
Quote:
I have trouble inserting the disc and insert the DVD disc in the case of the pin, sometimes scratches the disk, which the right way to fit and remove the pin disk the case of DVD? |
Pushing in on the center bump will often release the disc, but that will depend on the specific case design. Prying the disk out by the edge stresses the disc and should be avoided.
The black case should protect from light, and it can slow down the rate of temperature/humidity/air change if there is a sudden change in the local ambient environment. As indicated above, the unknown is whether or not the plastic out-gasses fumes that are harmful to the disc. And of course there are mechanical damage issues such as scratches, or stress cracks due to difficulty with disk insertion/removal. That can vary from make/brand to make/brand and even lot to lot from the same source. |
Quote:
I bought cases dvd amaray (not slim) black but I have not received them to find out if they are good or bad, it was the best I have found in Brazil dvd black case is higher than the cases of cd? it is true that the temperature on the disc is better in case of black dvd? |
In direct sun (or other intense direct heat source) the black case and its contents will get hot (a bit like a greenhouse effect). But if fully shaded from heat sources (the IR light), it should be OK.
The case provides a bit if insulation and air space that will slow the transfer of environmental changes such as heat to/from the disc,; e.g., It will warm slower but stay warm longer than if there is no case when the temperature changes. See lordsmurf's note on Amary. |
1 Attachment(s)
1 if the case black dvd then heat will heat the disk? I should be buying a non-black case dvd not heat? the average temperature of my region is 30 to 36 ° C, do not place the case and dvd in the sun but the heat this worldwide
2 see photo: in such case the openings enters light on the disc? |
With a black case the heat that is an issue is direct sunshine (or from some other significant bright/hot radiant source) hitting it. And the case will feel hot, like teh inside of a car in the sun. Not likely an issue if in a shaded corner of a room. There it will be at about the room temperature.
The light entering the slits you point to may be insignificant, especially if not in direct sun, and if the case has a cover insert that blocks the openings, or it is next to another case that blocks the openings. Don't over think the question! You are trying to polish a piece of excrement, and in the end you will still have a piece of excrement. Note: if the cases smell of solvent, that quite likely is not a good sign for optimal life. |
Site design, images and content © 2002-2026 The Digital FAQ, www.digitalFAQ.com
Forum Software by vBulletin · Copyright © 2026 Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.