Bye Bye Avisynth 2.5

[jamesp]

Well today i finally did it - i uninstalled Avisynth 2.5 and went back to trusty old 2.0.7. I tried and tried to use Avisynth 2.5, and it was certainly much, much faster. However, it continually buggered up my machine. These were the following problems i've had;

*) System just locks up at random points during the encode. After going back to 2.0.7 my machine hasn't locked once.
*) Blue Screen with Device Error. This never happened with 2.0.7.
*) Memory leaks. Occasionally, my hard drive would go mad and my machine became very unresponsive, and Windows would tell me I didn't have enough virtual memory. Back to 2.0.7 where i have never had this problem.

After going back to 2.0.7, i stressed tested my PC and my machine has been encoding constantly (tv captures) for a day and a half. Not a single problem yet. These same captures caused all sorts of probs with 2.5.
I think the work the avisynth team does is wonderful, but 2.5 is only a beta and hopefully these issues will get sorted.

Anyone else had problems with 2.5

Jim

[kwag]

Hi Jim,

Ditto on all your comments. I'm using 2.08 without any problems now. Guess we need to led avisynth 2.5x thaw for a while

-kwag

[jamesp]

Nice to know i'm not the only one!

I'm under no illusions that it is probably PC related. I posted this message at Doom9

http://forum.doom9.org/showthread.ph...threadid=49394

And they suggested trying a tool that stress tests your machine. Mine reports a problem during the test, but doesn't hang my machine. However, i've tried the same test on all my friends and families machines and every single one reports a problem at some stage during the stress test. I imagine the latest version of avisynth is written using Assembler where ever possible and any problem can cause a machine to hang, rather than crash gracefully!

Jim

Quote:

Originally Posted by kwag

Hi Jim,

Ditto on all your comments. I'm using 2.08 without any problems now. Guess we need to led avisynth 2.5x thaw for a while

-kwag

[/url]

[vico1]

I`ve run into somewhat similar probs using v2.5x on my machine.
(P4@1.7ghz 512MB)

I went to v2.08....no probs. (stick with "the devil you know", I guess)



*********************************
The Devil....is in the Details

[sh0dan]

Your choice - you should however have check your hardware with Prime96, as it is most likely unstable.

2.5 is soon leaving beta stage, and there will be no more updates of 2.0 after that - from me anyway.

[jamesp]

As i said, i've no doubt its related to my PC, as Prime95 says i get some sort of floating point error very quickly into the test. However, its amazing that i have never once had the crash using Avisynth 2.0.8. Eg, over the Easter Weekend i captured and encoded 10 Films - not one problem. Installed Avisynth 2.5 - it hung my machine at 10% on the first film.

However, I have since found out that the problem only occurs when i use AviSource combined with ConvertToYV12(). I can encode DVD rips with no problems in avisynth 2.5 (in the YV12 colour space). So maybe there is a bug lingering in there somewhere when converting from YUY2 to YV12?

Jim

Quote:

Originally Posted by sh0dan

Your choice - you should however have check your hardware with Prime96, as it is most likely unstable.

2.5 is soon leaving beta stage, and there will be no more updates of 2.0 after that - from me anyway.

[kwag]

Quote:

Originally Posted by sh0dan

2.5 is soon leaving beta stage, and there will be no more updates of 2.0 after that - from me anyway.

Hi sh0dan,

Does this mean that 2.5 will be considered "stable", just as stable as the 2.0x branch ?

-kwag

[sh0dan]

There is still a few issues with some internal filters, that should be fixed before it can happend (temporalsoften, some audio plugins come to mind), but the core appears very stable.

Also a solution to the "caching issue", where we were working on rewriting the cache, should preferably be finished, but we have been unable to find a good solution so far - even though we are still working on it.

All (serious) bugs found in 2.5 have also been fixed in 2.0, so of course 2.0 is still the most stable, if you only need that functionality. However the YV12 colorspace opens many possibilities for optimizations and filters.
Conditional filtering is a whole other issue, where we are only scratching the surface for now, which will bring loads of power to the users.

[kwag]

That's great sh0dan.
Will keep a close eye on your development

-kwag

[Jellygoose]

Where can I get Prime96 to check my hardware?

[kwag]

Try here Jellygoose http://www.mersenne.org/freesoft.htm

-kwag