with and without temporalsmoother(1,2)
comparing some results, i see that in dark scenes shows "obscures" green colors.
it's a really ugly dark green
removing the filters one by one,only stay
with unfilter and temporalsmoother filters.
in bright scenes all hue (matiz) are changed,
the skin faces seems like "anemic"
black hair is opaque wrapped in muddy cloud.
the image in general show LESS NOISES
without temporalsmoother, the dark scenes came to black,
got more contrast and normal colors,
but with MORE NOISES
then i did samples with and without temporalsmoother to compare.
the results in MPEG1 SVCD adjusting to 284 mb spacing free,
and free audio size to 0 (zero) in ToK
the script was edited for each case to encode:
Legalclip()
Unfilter(50,50)
BicubicResize(448,448,0,0.6,0,0,720,480)
"with and without temporalfilter(1,2)"
AddBorders(16,16,16,16)
Legalclip()
1-finding prediction using sample with 00:31:22
from ToK
Resolution (fps):480x480 (29,970 fps)
Total Frames: 56417
Total Time : 00:31:22 <---for predictions
CQ found (time and size here are irrelevants)
unfilter WITH temporalsmoother(1,2)
Next CQ: 70,473. Sample Size: 4.694.221
Exit Condition: 1,000 % reached ! yahoo !
Final CQ: 70,473
unfilter WITHOUT temporalsmoother
Next CQ: 63,472. Sample Size: 4.694.083
Exit Condition: 1,000 % reached ! yahoo !
Final CQ: 63,472
2-using the final predictions obtained,
selectin period with trim in the end of script
trim(30000,32000) <---selection for encode
from ToK
Resolution (fps):480x480 (29,970 fps)
Total Frames: 2001
Total Time : 00:01:07 <---for encode final CQs
TIMES and SIZES after encode
unfilter WITH temporalsmoother(1,2)
Encoding... CQ : 70,470
Final Encoded Size: 11.439.732
Total Time (all operations): 00:04:01
unfilter WITHOUT temporalsmoother
Encoding... CQ : 63,470
Final Encoded Size: 10.852.522
Total Time (all operations): 00:03:35
now i'm "dazed&confused".
what is better
with temporalsmoother and
bad colors,more CQ,more size, more time to encode
or
without temporalsmoother and
real colors, less CQ,less size, less time to encode
i can't answer this after hours testing and comparing
i need your point of view