I have the same issue with some home spun vhs tapes. I have resolved myself to the fact that some vhs material simply will not capture using the Ati board. I did the same thing as you, I switched vcr's, purchased high quality rca cables, tried different refresh rates on the monitor, tried to adjust the gamma, used manual tracking, tried the coax cabling, tried the macrovision hacks (That apparently DON'T work on 9600's, which is what I have also) and nothing seems to work. I don't have the money for a Data Video TBC 1000 yet, but I thought maybe that would help. I am also considering buying one of those Canopus ADVC-100(?) devices to see if that might work. Like you mention, the picture is bad in the TV viewer so I don't think it is macrovision in the first place. Funny side note is: Some vhs that should be macrovision protected, seems to capture without a hitch. Go figure