Both of those have issues.
Not the worst (ie, not an Easycap aka Easycrap; not Elgato junk), but also not good/best.
Cards sold "new" in the 2020s are not what you want do quality capture. Not just image quality, but a quality capture experience. Everything you see on Amazon
is cheap Chinese USB junk, HD that "also does" SD (and badly), or 2nd-tier cards that were passed over in the 00s-10s (ie, why still stocked, mostly NOS).